Sunday, September 2, 2012

The Tomato Report

I thought I'd give a brief review of some of the tomato varieties I grew this year. Unfortunately I don't have any good pictures of the individual types, because often once I get them in the house I start mixing them up to let them ripen and often can't remember which is which!
I started out in early spring planting 20 (yes, 20!) varieties of tomato. Ultimately they didn't all make it into the garden. While I was hardening off the plants I ran into trouble for the first time ever; the seedlings got sun-scalded and later developed some disease symptoms. I thought I was going to lose them all. However, once they were planted out they seemed to overcome those initial problems and grew well for awhile until the symptoms of early blight began somewhat sooner than usual.
I had a good mix of heirlooms and hybrids, figuring the hybrids had the better shot at overcoming disease and would be more productive. This may be true, but I honestly haven't seen a huge difference.
All in all, it hasn't been a good tomato year. My poor tomato plants really don't get enough sun and the disease has made for very weak plants. But anyway, let me make some comments on a few of the varieties:
For taste, I have to say the Red Brandywine and Cherokee Purple win hands down. They were delicious and I only wish we'd gotten a few more of them. On the opposite end of the taste scale was Indigo Rose. They were horrible! A huge disappointment. I like to try new and interesting varieties of vegetables so this tomato looked very intriguing. It boasted a deep purple color, almost black due to a very high lycopene content. Well, the color is only in the skin. The tomatoes are little salad types with an almost white flesh and they were watery and tasteless. I will not waste space in the garden on them next year.
Production kudos go to my Romas, which were large and plentiful despite growing on some pretty miserable looking plants. The Amish Paste, which I love, did very badly this year. The few I got were very small and tasteless, even though in the past they've grown huge and for a paste tomato are generally as tasty as the big slicers.
Also winners in the production department are Juliet, Eva Purple Ball and Burpee Big Boy. Which isn't saying much, because production in general was abyssmal.
I tried San Marzano for the first time. In the beginning I was very disappointed with them because they all had blossom end rot, but as the summer wore on, that disappeared and the tomatoes improved. Not sure if I'll grow them again though, because they were dry and mealy. If I had enough to make sauce, they'd be great, but just to can or eat, I find them pretty dull. Two heirlooms that have in the past given me huge and tasty tomatoes were Granny Cantrel's German Red and Henderson's Pink Ponderosa. This year the few they produced were small and unimpressive.
My Burpee Fourth of July has given a steady supply of small round tomatoes. It produced the very first tomato harvested in early July. The flavor is forgetable, but it is still chugging along.
Cherry tomatoes: Sungold is far and away the most delicious. I just wish it produced more! I also have Super Sweet 100, good taste. Also produced poorly.  Matt's Wild Cherry is very disease resistant and last year it produced well into the Fall. I find the very small tomatoes it produces annoying, but they do taste good. Riesentraube is an heirloom that produces a larger cherry that looks a lot like a Principe Borghese. Although I never get the big grape-like clusters pictured in the seed catalogues, they did produce a steady usable amount. The taste is average I think.
That covers most of the tomatoes. This is probably not the most accurate report due to the overall poor quality of this season's production. Some tomatoes that are usually stars in my garden really failed this year, but that doen't mean I won't plant them again. Then there are some that will not be back. And of course I'll always be looking to find a new winner!

12 comments:

  1. OOOh thank you I plan to begin planting my tomato seeds for this year - I too love heritage plants.
    Brandywine I've grown before but not Cherokee Purple. I'm not sure if I've seen Cherokee Purple will dig out my books this week.
    Nothing like a home grown tom is there?
    Love Leanne

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes Leanne, for you it is the season to start those tomatoes! The heritage tomatoes certainly taste the best! Cherokee Purple is a very popular variety here in the States; it is, as the name implies, dark in color, large and juicy. I will sure miss those nice tomatoes soon. My plants are almost dead, even though we will have warm weather for another month.

      Delete
  2. I'm sorry to hear about bad tomato season but completely agree on the review of CP, brandywine and Indigo Rose. I don't have the same varieties as you did but if you're looking for new to try the ones I liked were Striped German, Green Zebra, Black Brandywine (my favorite on taste), Black from Tula and Black Krim were all good taste wise, but they don't produce alot of tomatoes. Black Prince has small tomatoes but alot of them and very tasty. Grandma Oliver green variety was very tasty and surprised me so I'll be planting it again. I'll do full review shortly as well so you can see all varities I had.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Excellent Jenny! I will look into some of your suggestions next year for sure! Will look forward to your reviews!

      Delete
  3. You keep a nice detailed report of your tomatoes! I should but do not! Of course I do not have that many either but mine did very poorly this year and the skins were tough. Your still getting quite a few. You kind of people push my kind of poorly organized people along! lol Nancy

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ha, Nancy I am generally very disorganized, but the one way the German in me comes out is my obsessive need to record everything in writing.So I keep a number of journals, including the garden one with all my information for what it's worth!

      Delete
  4. You know all my San Marzano had blossom end rot as well. I only got a few tomatoes off the plants that didn't have it in the middle of summer. Mine did not produce as well as the other tomatoes I grew. Good post. I may have to do one as well :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'd love to see you do one Becky! That's how I choose new tomatoes to try, by seeing what other gardeners think.

      Delete
  5. I always enjoy reading veggie reviews. Even though I am now getting a ton of tomatoes, it really hasn't been a good year for them. I have found that they are not as tasty as they usually are. With regard to San Marzano tomatoes, I have yet to find a variety worth growing.

    I'll probably do my tomato review in October. Let's hope for a better year next year.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'll look forward to your reviews Robin! And I sure hope the tomatoes are better next year!

      Delete
  6. Thanks for the sharing your tomato grow-out! We had similar experience with Matt's Wild several years ago -- we liked that it's a heirloom, it's extremely productive and survived Late Blight when all others had succumbed, but exceedingly obnoxious to harvest...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So much going for it! If only it were a little bit larger!

      Delete